Thyroid benign (TBN) and malignant (TMN) nodules are a common thyroid lesion. The differentiation of TMN often remains a clinical challenge and further improvements of TMN diagnostic accuracy are warranted. The aim of present study was to evaluate possibilities of using differences in trace elements (TEs) contents in nodular tissue for diagnosis of thyroid malignancy.
Contents of TEs such as silver (Ag), aluminum (Al), boron (B),, beryllium (Be), bismuth (Bi), cadmium (Cd), cerium (Ce), cobalt (Co), chromium (Cr), cesium (Cs), iron (Fe), gallium (Ga), mercury (Hg), iodine (I), lanthanum (La), lithium (Li), manganese (Mn), molybdenum (Mo), neodymium (Nd), nickel (Ni), lead (Pb), praseodymium (Pr), rubidium (Rb), antimony (Sb), scandium (Sc), selenium (Se), samarium (Sm), tin (Sn), thallium (Tl), uranium (U), yttrium (Y), and zinc (Zn) were prospectively evaluated in nodular tissue of thyroids with TBN (79 patients) and to TMN (41 patients). Measurements were performed using a combination of non-destructive instrumental neutron activation analysis with high resolution spectrometry of short- and long-lived radionuclides (INAA-SLR and INAA-LLR, respectively) and destructive method such as inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS).
It was observed that in TMN tissue the mean mass fractions of Be, Fe, I, Sc, and Se are approximately 1.9, 1.7, 14, 3.1, and 1.6 times, respectively, lower while the mass fraction of Ga, Mo, and Rb 62%, 51%, and 33%, respectively, higher than those in TBN tissue. Contents of Ag, Al, B, Bi, Cd, Ce, Co, Cr, Cs, Hg, La, Li, Mn, Nd, Ni, Pb, Pr, Sb, Sm, Sn, Tl, U, Y, and Zn found in the TBN and TMN groups of nodular tissue samples were similar.
It was proposed to use the I mass fraction, as well as I/Ga, I/Mo, and I/Rb mass fraction ratios in a needle-biopsy of thyroid nodules as a potential tool to diagnose thyroid malignancy. Further studies on larger number of samples are required to confirm our findings and proposals.
Copyright © 2022 Vladimir Zaichick
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Nodules are a common thyroid lesion, particularly in women. Depending on the method of examination and general population, thyroid nodules (TNs) have an incidence of 19–68% 1. In clinical practice, TNs are classified into benign (TBN) and malignant (TMN), and among all TNs approximately 10% are TMN 2. It is appropriate mention here that the incidence of TMN is increasing rapidly (about 5% each year) worldwide 2. Surgical treatment is not always necessary for TBN whereas surgical treatment is required in TMN. Thus, differentiating TBN and TMN will have a great influence on thyroid therapy.
Ultrasound scan (USS) examination is widely used as the primary method for early detection and diagnosis of the TNs. However, there are many similarities in the USS characteristics of both TBN and TMN. For misdiagnosis prevention some computer-diagnosis systems based on the analysis of USS images were developed, however as usual these systems for the diagnosis of TMN showed accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity nearly 80% 2, 3. Therefore, when USS examination shows suspicious signs, an US-guided fine-needle aspiration biopsy is advised. Despite the fact that fine needle aspiration biopsy has remained the diagnostic tool of choice for evaluation of USS suspicious thyroid nodules, the differentiation of TMN often remains a diagnostic and clinical challenge since up to 30% of nodules are categorized as cytologically “indeterminate” 4. Thus, to improve diagnostic accuracy of TMN, new technologies have to be developed for clinical applications. However, a recent systematic review and meta-analysis of molecular tests in the preoperative diagnosis of indeterminate TNs has shown that presently there is no perfect biochemical, immunological, and genetic biomarkers to discriminate malignancy 5. Therefore, further improvements of TMN diagnostic accuracy are warranted.
During the last decades it was demonstrated that besides iodine deficiency and excess many other dietary, environmental, and occupational factors are associated with the TNs incidence 3, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11. Among these factors a disturbance of evolutionary stable input of many trace elements (TEs) in human body after the industrial revolution plays a significant role in etiology of TNs 12. Besides iodine, many other TEs have also essential physiological role and involved in thyroid functions 13. Essential or toxic (goitrogenic, mutagenic, carcinogenic) properties of TEs depend on tissue-specific need or tolerance, respectively 13.Excessive accumulation or an imbalance of the TEs may disturb the cell functions and may result in cellular proliferation, degeneration, death, benign or malignant transformation 13, 14, 15.
In our previous studies the complex of in vivo and in vitro nuclear analytical and related methods was developed and used for the investigation of iodine and other TEs contents in the normal and pathological thyroid 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22. Iodine level in the normal thyroid was investigated in relation to age, gender and some non-thyroidal diseases 23, 24. After that, variations of many TEs content with age in the thyroid of males and females were studied and age- and gender-dependence of some TEs was observed 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41. Furthermore, a significant difference between some TEs contents in colloid goiter, thyroiditis, thyroid adenoma, and cancer in comparison with normal thyroid and thyroid tissue adjacent to TNs was demonstrated 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51.
The present study had two aims. The main objective was to assess the silver (Ag), aluminum (Al), boron (B), beryllium (Be), bismuth (Bi), cadmium (Cd), cerium (Ce), cobalt (Co), chromium (Cr), cesium (Cs), iron (Fe), gallium (Ga), mercury (Hg), iodine (I), lanthanum (La), lithium (Li), manganese (Mn), molybdenum (Mo), neodymium (Nd), nickel (Ni), lead (Pb), praseodymium (Pr), rubidium (Rb), antimony (Sb), scandium (Sc), selenium (Se), samarium (Sm), tin (Sn), thallium (Tl), uranium (U), yttrium (Y), and zinc (Zn) contents in nodular tissue of patients who had either TBN or TMN using a combination of non-destructive instrumental neutron activation analysis with high resolution spectrometry of short- and long-lived radionuclides (INAA-SLR and INAA-LLR, respectively) and destructive method such as inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). The second aim was to compare the levels of TEs in TBN and TMN and to evaluate possibilities of using TEs differences for diagnosis of thyroid malignancy.
Material and Methods
All patients suffered from TBN (n=79, mean age M±SD was 44±11 years, range 22-64) and from TMN (n=41, mean age M±SD was 46±15 years, range 16-75) were hospitalized in the Head and Neck Department of the Medical Radiological Research Centre (MRRC), Obninsk. Thick-needle puncture biopsy of suspicious nodules of the thyroid was performed for every patient, to permit morphological study of thyroid tissue at these sites and to estimate their TEs contents. In all cases the diagnosis has been confirmed by clinical and morphological results obtained during studies of biopsy and resected materials. Histological conclusions for TBN were: 46 colloid goiter, 19 thyroid adenoma, 8 Hashimoto's thyroiditis, and 6 Riedel’s Struma, whereas for TMN were: 25 papillary adenocarcinomas, 8 follicular adenocarcinomas, 7 solid carcinomas, and 1 reticulosarcoma. Samples of nodular tissue for TEs analysis were taken from both biopsy and resected materials.
All studies were approved by the Ethical Committees of MRRC. All the procedures performed in studies involving human participants were in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional and/or national research committee and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments, or with comparable ethical standards. Informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study.
All tissue samples obtained from TBN and TMN were divided into two portions using a titanium scalpel to prevent contamination by TEs of stainless steel 52. One was used for morphological study while the other was intended for TEs analysis. After the samples intended for TEs analysis were weighed, they were freeze-dried and homogenized 53.
To determine contents of the TEs by comparison with a known standard, biological synthetic standards (BSS) prepared from phenol-formaldehyde resins were used 54. In addition to BSS, aliquots of commercial, chemically pure compounds were also used as standards. Ten sub-samples of certified reference material (CRM) IAEA H-4 (animal muscle) and five sub-samples of CRM of the Institute of Nuclear Chemistry and Technology (INCT, Warszawa, Poland) INCT-SBF-4 Soya Bean Flour, INCT-TL-1 Tea Leaves, and INCT-MPH-2 Mixed Polish Herbs were treated and analyzed in the same conditions like thyroid samples to estimate the precision and accuracy of results .
The content of I were determined by INAA-SLR using a horizontal channel equipped with the pneumatic rabbit system of the WWR-c research nuclear reactor (Branch of Karpov Institute, Obninsk). Details of used nuclear reaction, radionuclide, gamma-energies, spectrometric unit, sample preparation, and the quality control of results were presented in our earlier publications concerning the INAA-SLR of I contents in human thyroid 27, 28 and scalp hair 55.
A vertical channel of the same nuclear reactor was applied to determine the content of Ag, Co, Cr, Fe, Hg, Rb, Sb, Sc, Se, and Zn by INAA-LLR. Details of used nuclear reactions, radionuclides, gamma-energies, spectrometric unit, sample preparation and procedure of measurement were presented in our earlier publications concerning the INAA-LLR of TEs contents in human thyroid 29, 30, scalp hair 55, and prostate 56, 57, 58, 59.
After non-destructive INAA-LLR investigation the thyroid samples were used for ICP-MS. The samples were decomposed in autoclaves and aliquots of solutions were used to determine the Ag, Al, As, Au, B, Be, Bi, Cd, Ce, Co, Cr, Cs, Dy, Er, Eu, Ga, Gd, Hg, Ho, Ir, La, Li, Lu, Mn, Mo, Nb, Nd, Ni, Pb, Pd, Pr, Pt, Rb, Sb, Se, Sm, Sn, Tb, Te, Th, Ti, Tl, Tm, U, Y, Yb, Zn, and Zr mass fractions by ICP-MS using an ICP-MS Thermo-Fisher “X-7” Spectrometer (Thermo Electron, USA). Information detailing with the NAA-LLR and ICP-MS methods used and other details of the analysis were presented in our earlier publications concerning TE contents in human thyroid 29, 30, 35, prostate 60, 61, 62, and scalp hair 55.
A dedicated computer program for INAA-SLR and INAA-LLR mode optimization was used 63. All thyroid samples were prepared in duplicate, and mean values of TEs contents were used in final calculation. Mean values of TEs contents were used in final calculation for the Ag, Co, Cr, Hg, Rb, Sb, Se, and Zn mass fractions measured by INAA-LLR and ICP-MS methods. Using Microsoft Office Excel software, a summary of the statistics, including, arithmetic mean, standard deviation of mean, standard error of mean, minimum and maximum values, median, percentiles with 0.025 and 0.975 levels was calculated for TEs contents in two groups of nodular tissue (TBN and TMN). The difference in the results between two groups of samples was evaluated by the parametric Student’s t-test and non-parametric Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney U-test.
Table 1 and Table 2 depict certain statistical parameters (arithmetic mean, standard deviation, standard error of mean, minimal and maximal values, median, percentiles with 0.025 and 0.975 levels) of the Ag, Al, B, Be, Bi, Cd, Ce, Co, Cr, Cs, Fe, Ga, Hg, I, La, Li, Mn, Mo, Nd, Ni, Pb, Pr, Rb, Sb, Sc, Se, Sm, Sn, Tl, U, Y, and Zn mass fraction in two groups of samples - TBN and TMN, respectively.Table 1. Some statistical parameters of 32 trace element mass fraction (mg/kg, dry mass basis) in thyroid benign nodules (TBN)
|Element||M||SD||SEM||Min||Max||Median||P 0.025||P 0.975|
|Element||M||SD||SEM||Min||Max||Median||P 0.025||P 0.975|
The ratios of means and the comparison of mean values of Ag, Al, B, Be, Bi, Cd, Ce, Co, Cr, Cs, Fe, Ga, Hg, I, La, Li, Mn, Mo, Nd, Ni, Pb, Pr, Rb, Sb, Sc, Se, Sm, Sn, Tl, U, Y, and Zn mass fractions in pair of sample groups such as TBN and TMN is presented in Table 3.Table 3. Differences between mean values (M±SEM) of 32 trace element mass fractions (mg/kg, dry mass basis) in thyroid benign (TBN) and malignant (TMN) nodules
|TBN||TMN||Student’s t-test, p£||U-test, p||TMN / TBN|
The comparison of our results with published data for Ag, Al, B, Be, Bi, Cd, Ce, Co, Cr, Cs, Fe, Ga, Hg, I, La, Li, Mn, Mo, Nd, Ni, Pb, Pr, Rb, Sb, Sc, Se, Sm, Sn, Tl, U, Y, and Zn mass fraction in TBN 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77 and TMN 70, 71, 72 is shown in Table 4 and Table 5, respectively. A number of values for TEs mass fractions were not expressed on a dry mass basis by the authors of the cited references. However, we calculated these values using published data for water (75%) 84 and ash (4.16% on dry mass basis) 85 contents in thyroid of adults.Table 4. Median, minimum and maximum value of means of trace element contents in thyroid benign nodules (TBN) according to data from the literature in comparison with our results (mg/kg, dry mass basis)
|Element||Published data (Reference)||This work|
|Medianof means(n)*||Minimumof means M or M±SD, (n)**||Maximumof means M or M±SD, (n)**||Males and females(combined) M±SD|
|Ag||0.16 (4)||0.098±0.042 (19) 64||1.20±2.28 (51) 65||0.192±0.199|
|Al||3.84 (5)||2.45 (123) 66||840 (25) 67||27.3±23.6|
|Cd||0.499 (2)||0.125±0.006 (64) 68||1.72±0.13 (9) 69||1.55±1.68|
|Co||0.86 (13)||0.110±0.003 (64) 68||62.8±22.4 (11) 70||0.0576±0.0324|
|Cr||4.0 (6)||0.72 (51) 64||146±14 (4) 71||1.17±1.19|
|Fe||207 (9)||54.6±36.1 (5) 72||4848±3056 (11) 70||430±566|
|Hg||79.2 (1)||79.2±8.0 (4) 71||79.2±8.0 (4) 71||1.15±1.04|
|I||812 (55)||77±14 (66) 73||2800 (4) 74||992±901|
|Mn||1.82 (4)||0.40±0.22 (64) 75||57.6±6.0 (4) 71||1.81±1.41|
|Mo||0.25 (4)||0.094-0.145 (77) 64||512±16 (11) 70||0.193±0.121|
|Ni||0.93 (11)||0.404 (41) 75||19.7±20.5 (11) 70||2.89±2.52|
|Pb||0.79 (12)||0.156±0.156 (9) 69||46.4±4.8 (4) 71||1.31±2.27|
|Rb||7.5 (2)||7,0 (10) 76||864±148 (11) 70||9.50±4.23|
|Se||1.97 (9)||0.248 (41) 75||174±116 (11) 70||3.20±2.92|
|U||0.15 (5)||0.00052 (46) 75||0.28±0.25 (51) 65||0.00116±0.00059|
|Zn||112 (13)||48±8 (5) 75||494±37 (2) 77||117.7±48.7|
|Element||Published data (Reference)||This work|
|Medianof means (n)*||Minimumof means M or M±SD, (n)**||Maximumof means M or M±SD, (n)**||Males and females(combined) M±SD|
|Cd||0.764 (1)||0.764±0.140 (5) 78||0.764±0.140 (5) 78||1.13±1.82|
|Co||71.6 (3)||2.48±0.85 (18) 79||94.4±69.6 (3) 70||0.0499±0.0292|
|Cr||2.74 (2)||1.04±0.52 (4) 77||119±12 (4) 71||1.85±1.81|
|Fe||304 (8)||48.5 (2) 72||5588±556 (4) 71||255±168|
|Hg||14.4 (2)||0.04±0.03 (92) 80||30.8±3.2 (4) 71||0.915±0.826|
|I||78.8 (12)||<23±10 (8) 81||800 (1) 82||71.8±62.0|
|Mn||1.95 (9)||0.54 (40) 75||186±18 (4) 71||2.01±1.34|
|Ni||1.62 (5)||0.192 (66) 75||30.8±2.8 (4) 71||4.38±2.24|
|Pb||2.02 (8)||0.062 (40) 75||72 (1) 83||1.14±1.16|
|Rb||14.7 (2)||11,5 (10) 76||17.8±9.7 (5) 76||12.65±4.87|
|Se||2.14 (11)||0.264 (66) 75||241±296 (3) 70||2.04±1.06|
|U||0.00029 (1)||0.00028 (40) 75||0.00032 (85) 75||0.00514±0.01109|
|Zn||92.4 (20)||22.6 (85) 75||494±37 (2) 77||96.9±80.0|
As was shown before 27, 28, 29, 30 good agreement of the Ag, Al, B, Be, Bi, Cd, Ce, Co, Cr, Cs, Fe, Ga, Hg, I, La, Li, Mn, Mo, Nd, Ni, Pb, Pr, Rb, Sb, Sc, Se, Sm, Sn, Tl, U, Y, and Zn contents in CRM IAEA H-4, INCT-SBF-4, INCT-TL-1, and INCT-MPH-2 samples determined by both INAA-SLR and ICP-MS methods with the certified data of these CRMs indicates acceptable accuracy of the results obtained in the study of TBN and TMN groups of tissue samples presented in Table 1, Table 2, Table 3, Table 4, Table 5
From Table 3, it is observed that in TMN tissue the mean mass fractions of Be, Fe, I, Sc, and Se are approximately 1.9, 1.7, 14, 3.1, and 1.6 times, respectively, lower while the mass fraction of Ga, Mo, and Rb were 62%, 51%, and 33%, respectively, higher than those in TBN tissue. In a general sense Ag, Al, B, Bi, Cd, Ce, Co, Cr, Cs, Hg, La, Li, Mn, Nd, Ni, Pb, Pr, Sb, Sm, Sn, Tl, U, Y, and Zn contents found in the TBN and TMN groups of tissue samples were similar (Table 3).
Mean values obtained for Ag, Al, Cd, Cr, Fe, I, Mn, Mo, Ni, Pb, Rb, Se, and Zn contents in TBN agree well with median of mean values reported by other researches (Table 4). Mean mass fractions of Co, Hg, and U in TBN obtained in present study were almost two order of magnitude lower medians of means for these TEs in published articles. No published data referring B, Be, Bi,Cs, Ga,La, Li, Nd, Pr, Sb, Sc, Sm, Sn, Tl, and Y contents of TBN were found (Table 4).
Mean values obtained for Cd, Cr, Fe, I, Mn, Ni, Pb, Rb, Se, and Zn contents in TMN agree well with median of mean values reported by other researches (Table 5). Mean mass fraction obtained for Co and Hg in TMN were approximately two and one order of magnitude, respectively, lower median of previously reported means. Mean mass fraction of U founded in TMN was almost one order of magnitude higher the only published result 75. No published data referring Ag, Al, B, Be, Bi, Ce, Cs, Ga, La, Li, Mo, Nd, Pr, Sb, Sc, Sm, Sn, Tl, and Y contents of TMN were found (Table 5).
The range of means of Ag, Al, Cd, Co, Cr, Fe, I, Mn, Mo, Ni, Pb, Rb, Se, U and Zn level reported in the literature for TBN and TMN vary widely (Table 3). This can be explained by a dependence of TEs content on many factors, including age, gender, ethnicity, mass of the TNs, and the stage of diseases. Not all these factors were strictly controlled in cited studies. However, in our opinion, the leading causes of inter-observer variability can be attributed to the accuracy of the analytical techniques, sample preparation methods, and inability of taking uniform samples from the affected tissues. It was insufficient quality control of results in these studies. In many scientific reports, tissue samples were ashed or dried at high temperature for many hours. In other cases, thyroid samples were treated with solvents (distilled water, ethanol, formalin etc). There is evidence that during ashing, drying and digestion at high temperature some quantities of certain TEs are lost as a result of this treatment. That concerns not only such volatile element as Hg, but also other TEs investigated in the study 86, 87, 88. On the other hand, when destructive analytical techniques are used the tissue samples may be contaminated by TEs contained in chemicals used for digestion.
Trace elemental analysis of affected thyroid tissue could become a powerful diagnostic tool. To a large extent, the resumption of the search for new methods for early diagnosis of TMN was due to experience gained in a critical assessment of the limited capacity of the USS-examination 2, 3. In addition to the US test and morphological study of needle-biopsy of the TNs, the development of other highly precise testing methods seems to be very useful. Experimental conditions of the present study were approximated to the hospital conditions as closely as possible. In all cases we analyzed a part of the material obtained from a puncture biopsy of the TNs. Therefore, our data allow us to evaluate adequately the importance of TEs content information for distinguishing TMN from TBN.
Tissue content of Ga, Be, Fe, I, Mo, Rb, Sc, and Se are different in most TMN as compared to TBN (Table 3). Level of I in nodular tissue has very promising prospects as a biomarker of malignancy, because there is a great difference between content of this TE in TBN and TMN (Table 3). It is very interest a potential possibilities of using the I/Ga, I/Mo, and I/Rb ratio as cancer biomarker, because during the thyroid malignant transformation contents of these TEs in nodular tissue change in different directions – a drastically decrease of I and an increase of Ga, Mo, Rb (Table 3). Thus, the results of study show that analysis of TEs contents in biopsy of TNs may serve as a potential tool for detection of TMN.
This study has several limitations. Firstly, analytical techniques employed in this study measure only thirty two TEs (Ag, Al, B, Be, Bi, Cd, Ce, Co, Cr, Cs, Fe, Ga, Hg, I, La, Li, Mn, Mo, Nd, Ni, Pb, Pr, Rb, Sb, Sc, Se, Sm, Sn, Tl, U, Y, and Zn) mass fractions. Future studies should be directed toward using other analytical methods which will extend the list of TEs investigated in TBN and TMN. Secondly, the sample size of TBN and TMN group was relatively small and prevented investigations of TEs contents in this group using differentials like gender, functional activity of nodules, stage of disease, and dietary habits of patients with TNs. Lastly, generalization of our results may be limited to Russian population. Despite these limitations, this study provides evidence on significant TEs level alteration in thyroid nodular tissue and shows the necessity to continue TEs research as potential biomarkers of thyroid malignant transformation.
In this work, trace elemental analysis was carried out in the nodular tissue samples of thyroid with TBN and TMN using instrumental neutron activation analysis. It was shown that a combination of non-destructive instrumental neutron activation analysis and destructive method such as inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry is an adequate analytical tool for the determination of Ag, Al, B, Be, Bi, Cd, Ce, Co, Cr, Cs, Fe, Ga, Hg, I, La, Li, Mn, Mo, Nd, Ni, Pb, Pr, Rb, Sb, Sc, Se, Sm, Sn, Tl, U, Y, and Zn content in the tissue samples of human thyroid, including needle-biopsy material. It was observed that in TMN tissue the mean mass fractions of Be, Fe, I, Sc, and Se are approximately 1.9, 1.7, 14, 3.1, and 1.6 times, respectively, lower while the mass fraction of Ga, Mo, and Rb 62%, 51%, and 33%, respectively, higher than those in TBN tissue. Contents of Ag, Al, B, Bi, Cd, Ce, Co, Cr, Cs, Hg, La, Li, Mn, Nd, Ni, Pb, Pr, Sb, Sm, Sn, Tl, U, Y, and Zn found in the TBN and TMN groups of nodular tissue samples were similar. In our opinion, the drastically decrease in level I and abnormal increase in Ga, Mo, and Rb level in thyroid nodular tissue could be a specific consequence of malignant transformation. It was proposed to use the I mass fraction, as well as I/Ga, I/Mo, and I/Rb mass fraction ratio in a needle-biopsy of thyroid nodules as a potential tool to diagnose thyroid malignancy. Further studies on larger number of samples are required to confirm our findings and proposals.
There were no any sources of funding that have supported this work.
The author is extremely grateful to Profs. Vtyurin BM and Medvedev VS, Medical Radiological Research Center, Obninsk, as well as to Dr. Choporov Yu, former Head of the Forensic Medicine Department of City Hospital, Obninsk, for supplying thyroid samples. The author is also grateful to Dr. Karandaschev V, Dr. Nosenko S, and Moskvina I, Institute of Microelectronics Technology and High Purity Materials, Chernogolovka, Russia, for their help in ICP-MS analysis.
- 1.Fresilli D, David E, Pacini P, Gaudio G D, Dolcetti V et al. (2021) Thyroid Nodule Characterization: How to Assess the Malignancy Risk. Update of the Literature.Diagnostics (Basel). 11(8), 1374.
- 2.Jin Z, Zhu Y, Zhang S, Xie F, Zhang M et al. (2020) Ultrasound Computer-Aided Diagnosis (CAD) based on the Thyroid Imaging Reporting and Data System (TI-RADS) to distinguish benign from malignant thyroid nodules and the diagnostic performance of radiologists with different diagnostic experience.Med Sci Monit. 26-918452.
- 3.Trimboli P, Castellana M, Piccardo A, Romanelli F, Grani G et al. (2021) The ultrasound risk stratification systems for thyroid nodule have been evaluated against papillary carcinoma. A meta-analysis.Rev Endocr Metab Disord. 22(2), 453-460.
- 4.Patel S G, Carty S E, Lee A J. (2021) Molecular testing for thyroid nodules including its interpretation and use in clinical practice.Ann Surg Oncol. 28(13), 8884-8891.
- 5.Silaghi C A, Lozovanu V, Georgescu C E, Georgescu R D, Susman S et al. (2021) Thyroseq v3, Afirma GSC, and microRNA Panels versus previous molecular tests in the preoperative diagnosis of indeterminate thyroid nodules: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Front Endocrinol (Lausanne). 12, 649522.
- 7.Zaichick V, Iljina T. (1998) Dietary iodine supplementation effect on the rat thyroid131I blastomogenic action. In:. Die Bedentung der Mengen- und Spurenelemente. 18. Arbeitstangung. Friedrich-Schiller-Universität , Jena 294-306.
- 8.Kim K, Cho S W, Park Y J, Lee K E, Lee D-W et al. (2021) Association between iodine intake, thyroid function, and papillary thyroid cancer: A case-control study. Endocrinol Metab (Seoul). 36(4), 790-799.
- 9.Stojsavljević A, Rovčanin B, Krstić D, Borković-Mitić S, Paunović I et al. (2019) Risk assessment of toxic and essential trace metals on the thyroid health at the tissue level: The significance of lead and selenium for colloid goiter disease. Expo Health.
- 10.Fahim Y A, Sharaf N E, Hasani I W, Ragab E A, Abdelhakim H K. (2020) Assessment of thyroid function and oxidative stress state in foundry workers exposed to lead.J Health Pollut. 10(27), 200903.
- 11.Liu M, Song J, Jiang Y, Lin Y, Peng J et al. (2021) A case-control study on the association of mineral elements exposure and thyroid tumor and goiter.Ecotoxicol Environ Saf. 208-111615.
- 12.Zaichick V. (2006) Medical elementology as a new scientific discipline. , J Radioanal Nucl Chem 269, 303-309.
- 13.Moncayo R, Moncayo H. (2017) A post-publication analysis of the idealized upper reference value of 2.5 mIU/L for TSH: Time to support the thyroid axis with magnesium and iron especially in the setting of reproduction medicine.BBA. , Clin 7, 115-119.
- 14.Beyersmann D, Hartwig A. (2008) Carcinogenic metal compounds: recent insight into molecular and cellular mechanisms.Arch Toxicol. 82(8), 493-512.
- 15.Martinez-Zamudio R, Ha H C. (2011) Environmental epigenetics in metal exposure.Epigenetics. 6(7), 820-827.
- 16.Zaĭchik V, YuS Raibukhin, Melnik A D, Cherkashin. (1970) Neutron-activation analysis in the study of the behavior of iodine in the organism.Med Radiol (Mosk). 15(1), 33-36.
- 17.Zaĭchik V, Matveenko E G, Vtiurin B M, Medvedev V S. (1982) Intrathyroid iodine in the diagnosis of thyroid cancer.Vopr Onkol. 28(3), 18-24.
- 19.Zaichick V, YuYa Choporov. (1996) Determination of the natural level of human intra-thyroid iodine by instrumental neutron activation analysis. , J Radioanal Nucl Chem 207(1), 153-161.
- 20.Zaichick V. (1998) In vivo and in vitro application of energy-dispersive XRF in clinical investigations: experience and the future. , J Trace Elem Exp Med 11(4), 509-510.
- 21.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (1999) Energy-dispersive X-ray fluorescence of iodine in thyroid puncture biopsy specimens. , J Trace Microprobe Tech 17(2), 219-232.
- 22.Zaichick V. (2000) Relevance of, and potentiality for in vivo intrathyroidal iodine determination. , Ann N Y Acad Sci 904, 630-632.
- 24.Zaichick V. (1999) Human intrathyroidal iodine in health and non-thyroidal disease.New aspects of trace element research. (Smith-Gordon and Nishimura, London and Tokyo. 114-119.
- 25.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2017) Age-related changes of some trace element contents in intact thyroid of females investigated by energy dispersive X-ray fluorescent analysis. Trends Geriatr Healthc. 1(1), 31-38.
- 26.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2017) Age-related changes of some trace element contents in intact thyroid of males investigated by energy dispersive X-ray fluorescent analysis. MOJ Gerontol Ger. 1(5), 00028.
- 27.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2017) Age-related changes of Br, Ca, Cl, I, K, Mg, Mn, and Na contents in intact thyroid of females investigated by neutron activation analysis. Curr Updates Aging. 1, 5-1.
- 28.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2017) Age-related changes of Br, Ca, Cl, I, K, Mg, Mn, and Na contents in intact thyroid of males investigated by neutron activation analysis. J Aging Age Relat Dis. 1(1), 1002.
- 29.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2017) Age-related changes of Ag, Co, Cr, Fe, Hg, Rb, Sb, Sc, Se, and Zn contents in intact thyroid of females investigated by neutron activation analysis. J Gerontol Geriatr Med. , J Gerontol Geriatr Med 3, 015.
- 30.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2017) Age-related changes of Ag, Co, Cr, Fe, Hg, Rb, Sb, Sc, Se, and Zn contents in intact thyroid of males investigated by neutron activation analysis. Curr Trends Biomedical Eng Biosci. 4(4), 555644.
- 31.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2018) Effect of age on chemical element contents in female thyroid investigated by some nuclear analytical methods. MicroMedicine. 6(1), 47-61.
- 32.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2018) Neutron activation and X-ray fluorescent analysis in study of association between age and chemical element contents in thyroid of males.Op Acc J Bio Eng Bio Sci. 2(4), 202-212.
- 33.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2018) Variation with age of chemical element contents in females’ thyroids investigated by neutron activation analysis and inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectrometry. , J Biochem Analyt Stud 3(1), 1-10.
- 34.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2018) Association between age and twenty chemical element contents in intact thyroid of males. SM Gerontol Geriatr Res. 2(1), 1014.
- 35.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2018) Associations between age and 50 trace element contents and relationships in intact thyroid of males. Aging Clin Exp Res. 30(9), 1059-1070.
- 36.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2018) Possible role of inadequate quantities of intra-thyroidal bromine, rubidium and zinc in the etiology of female subclinical hypothyroidism. EC Gynaecology. 7(3), 107-115.
- 37.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2018) Possible role of inadequate quantities of intra-thyroidal bromine, calcium and magnesium in the etiology of female subclinical hypothyroidism. Int Gyn and Women’s Health. 1-3.
- 38.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2018) Possible role of inadequate quantities of intra-thyroidal cobalt, rubidium and zinc in the etiology of female subclinical hypothyroidism. Womens Health Sci. 2(1), 000108.
- 39.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2018) Association between female subclinical hypothyroidism and inadequate quantities of some intra-thyroidal chemical elements investigated by X-ray fluorescence and neutron activation analysis. Gynaecology and Perinatology. 2(4), 340-355.
- 40.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2018) Investigation of association between the high risk of female subclinical hypothyroidism and inadequate quantities of twenty intra-thyroidal chemical elements.Clin Res: Gynecol Obstet. 1(1), 1-18.
- 41.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2018) Investigation of association between the high risk of female subclinical hypothyroidism and inadequate quantities of intra-thyroidal trace elements using neutron activation and inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. Acta Scientific Medical Sciences. 2(9), 23-37.
- 42.Zaichick V.Comparison between trace element contents in macro and micro follicular colloid goiter using neutron activation analysis. , Journal of Clinical Research and Clinical Case Reports.2021; 2(2), 1-7.
- 43.Zaichick V. (2021) Trace element contents in thyroid of patients with diagnosed nodular goiter investigated by instrumental neutron activation analysis.Journal of Medical Research and Health Sciences. 4(8), 1405-1417.
- 44.Zaichick V.Comparison of trace element contents in normal and adenomatous thyroid investigated using instrumental neutron activation analysis. , Saudi J Biomed Res 6(11), 246-255.
- 45.Zaichick V. (2021) Evaluation of ten trace element in Riedel’s Struma using neutron activation analysis. Mod Res Clin Canc Prev. 1(1), 1-6.
- 46.Zaichick V. (2021) Comparison of trace element contents in normal thyroid and thyroid with Hashimoto's thyroiditis using neutron activation analysis. , World Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews 12(01), 503-511.
- 47.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2018) Trace element contents in thyroid cancer investigated by instrumental neutron activation analysis. J Oncol Res. 2(1), 1-13.
- 48.Zaichick V, Zaichick S.Determination of fifty trace element contents in macro and micro follicular colloid nodular goiter.American. , Journal of Biomedical Science & Research 13(6), 639-650.
- 49.Zaichick V. (2021) Determination of fifty trace element contents in normal and goitrous thyroid using a combination of instrumental neutron activation analysis and inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry.Metallomics Research. 1, 1-19.
- 50.Zaichick V.Evaluation of fifty trace element contents in thyroid adenomas using a combination of instrumental neutron activation analysis and inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. , Journal of Cancer and Oncology Research 2(3), 1-11.
- 51.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2018) Fifty trace element contents in normal and cancerous thyroid. Acta Scientific Cancer Biology. 2(8), 21-38.
- 52.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (1996) Instrumental effect on the contamination of biomedical samples in the course of sampling. , The Journal of Analytical Chemistry 51(12), 1200-1205.
- 53.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (1997) A search for losses of chemical elements during freeze-drying of biological materials. , J Radioanal Nucl Chem 218(2), 249-253.
- 54.Zaichick V. (1995) Applications of synthetic reference materials in the medical Radiological Research Centre. , Fresenius J Anal Chem 352, 219-223.
- 55.Zaichick S, Zaichick V. (2010) The effect of age and gender on 37 chemical element contents in scalp hair of healthy humans. Biol Trace Elem Res. 134(1), 41-54.
- 56.Zaichick S, Zaichick V. (2011) The effect of age on Ag, Co, Cr, Fe, Hg, Sb, Sc, Se, and Zn contents in intact human prostate investigated by neutron activation analysis. App Radiat Isot. 69(6), 827-833.
- 57.Zaichick V, Zaichick S.. INAA application in the assessment of Ag, Co, Cr, Fe, Hg, Rb, Sb, Sc, Se, and Zn mass fraction in pediatric and young adult prostate glands. J Radioanal Nucl Chem. , J Radioanal Nucl Chem 298(3), 1559-1566.
- 58.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2014) Relations of the neutron activation analysis data to morphometric parameters in pediatric and nonhyperplastic young adult prostate glands. Advances in Biomedical Science and Engineering 1(1), 26-42.
- 59.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2016) Variations in concentration and histological distribution of Ag, Co, Cr, Fe, Hg, Rb, Sb, Sc, Se, and Zn in nonhyperplastic prostate gland throughout adulthood. Jacobs Journal of Cell and Molecular Biology. , Jacobs Journal of Cell 2(1), 1-16.
- 60.Zaichick S, Zaichick V, Nosenko S, Moskvina I. (2012) Mass fractions of 52 trace elements and zinc trace element content ratios in intact human prostates investigated by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. Biol Trace Elem Res. 149(2), 171-183.
- 61.Zaichick V, Zaichick S.The distribution of 54 trace elements including zinc in pediatric and nonhyperplastic young adult prostate gland tissues. , Journal of Clinical and Laboratory Investigation Updates 2(1), 1-15.
- 62.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (2016) Age-related changes in concentration and histological distribution of 54 trace elements in nonhyperplastic prostate of adults. , Int Arch Urol Complic 2(2), 019.
- 63.Korelo A M, Zaichick V. (1993) Software to optimize the multielement INAA of medical and environmental samples. In: Activation Analysis in Environment Protection. Joint Institute for Nuclear Research;. , Dubna, Russia 326-332.
- 64.Predtechenskaya V C. (1975) Nucleic acids and trace elements in thyroid pathology. Proceedings of the Voronezh Medical Faculty 94, 85-87.
- 65.Antonova M V, Elinova V G, YaV Voitekhovskaya. (1966) Some trace element contents in thyroid and water in endemic goiter region. Zdravookhranenie BSSR. 9, 42-44.
- 66.Yanchur N M, Elenevskaya N S, But-Gusain A M, Nikhamkin L P. (1967) Contents of manganese, aluminum, copper, and zinc in bloos and thyroid of patients with goiter. Clinicheskaya Hirurgiya. 4, 27-20.
- 67.Kamenev V F. (1963) About trace element contents in thyroid of adults. In: Trace Elements in Agriculture and Medicine. Buryatia publishing-house, Ulan-Ude. 12-16.
- 68.Błazewicz A, Dolliver W, Sivsammye S, Deol A, Randhawa R et al. (2010) Błazewicz R.Determination of cadmium, cobalt, copper, iron, manganese, and zinc in thyroid glands of patients with diagnosed nodular goitre using ion chromatography.J Chromatogr B Analyt Technol Biomed Life Sci. 878(1), 34-38.
- 69.Zaripov C. (1975) Contents of some trace elements in normal and goitrous thyroid. In: Republic conference of young sientists and specialists of Tadzhik SSR. , Dushanbe 26-28.
- 70.Salimi J, Moosavi K, Vatankhah S, Yaghoobi A. (2004) Investigation of heavy trace elements in neoplastic and non-neoplastic human thyroid tissue: A study by proton – induced X-ray emissions. Iran J Radiat Res. 1(4), 211-216.
- 71.Reddy S B, Charles M J, Kumar M R, Reddy B, Ch Anjaneyulu et al. (2002) Trace elemental analysis of adenoma and carcinoma thyroid by. PIXE method.Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: BeamInteractionswith Materials and Atoms196(3-4): 333-339.
- 72.Maeda K, Yokode Y, Sasa Y, Kusuyama H.Uda M.1987;Multielemental analysis of human thyroid glands using particle induced X-ray emission (PIXE). Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms22(1-3): 188-190.
- 73.Błazewicz A, Orlicz-Szczesna G, Szczesny P, Prystupa A, Grzywa-Celinska A et al. (2011) A comparative analytical assessment of iodides in healthy and pathological human thyroids based on IC-PAD method preceded by microwave digestion. , Journal of Chromatography 879, 573-578.
- 74.Braasch J W, Abbert A, Keating F R, Black B M. (1955) A note of the iodinated constituents of normal thyroids and of exophthalmic goiters. , J Clin Endocrinol Metab 15(4), 732-738.
- 75.Stojsavljević A, Rovčanin B, Krstić D, Borković-Mitić S, Paunović I et al. (2019) Evaluation of trace metals in thyroid tissues: Comparative analysis with benign and malignant thyroid diseases.Ecotoxicol Environ Saf. 183-109479.
- 76.Kvicala J, Havelka J, Nemec J, Zeman V. (1992) Selenium and rubidium changes in subjects with pathologically altered thyroid. , Biol Trace Elem Res 32, 253-258.
- 77.Zagrodzki P, Nicol F, Arthur J R, Słowiaczek M, Walas S et al. (2010) Wietecha-Posłuszny R.Selenoenzymes, laboratory parameters, and trace elements in different types of thyroid tumor. Biol Trace Elem Res. 134(1), 25-40.
- 78.Yaman M,Akdeniz I.(2004) Sensitivity enhancement in flame atomic absorption spectrometry for determination of copper in human thyroid tissues.Anal Sci.20(9):. 1363-1366.
- 79.Neĭmark Timoshnikov VM. (1978) Development of thyroid cancer in persons living in the endemic goiter area.Probl Endokrinol (Mosk). 24(3), 28-32.
- 80.Chung HK,Nam JS,Ahn CW,Lee YS,Kim KR.2016; Some Elements. in Thyroid Tissue are Associated with More Advanced Stage of Thyroid Cancer in Korean Women.Biol Trace Elem Res.171(1): 54-62.
- 81.Nishida M, Sakurai H, Tezuka U, Kawada J, Koyama M et al. (1990) Alterations in manganese and iodide contents in human thyroid tumors; a correlation between the contents of essential trace elements and the states of malignancy. Clinica Chimica Acta. 187(2), 181-187.
- 82.Tardos T G, Maisey M N, Tang S C, Turner P C. (1981) The iodine concentration in binign and malignant thyroid nodules measured by X-Ray fluorescence. , Brit J Radiol 54, 626-629.
- 83.Jundt F C, Purser K H, Kubo H, Schenk E A. (1974) Proton-induced X-ray analysis of trace elements in tissue sections. J Histochem Cytochem. 22(1), 1-6.
- 84.Katoh Y, Sato T, Yamamoto Y. (2002) Determination of multielement concentrations in normal human organs from the Japanese.Biol Trace Elem Res.90(1):. 57-70.
- 85.Schroeder H A, Tipton I H, Nason A P. (1972) Trace metals in man: strontium and barium. J Chron Dis. 25(9), 491-517.
- 86.Zaichick V Sampling. (1997) sample storage and preparation of biomaterials for INAA in clinical medicine, occupational and environmental health. In: Harmonization of Health-Related Environmental Measurements Using Nuclear and Isotopic Techniques. , IAEA, Vienna 123-133.
- 87.Zaichick V, Zaichick S. (1997) A search for losses of chemical elements during freeze-drying of biological materials. , J Radioanal Nucl Chem 218(2), 249-253.